Skip to content
Donate Now! Merchandise

Stop 5 of 12

Workmen's Circle Hall

In 2010, many in Nashville thought this building was history. Instead it has become a historic preservation success. That year Historic Nashville Inc., a local nonprofit, placed Workmen’s Circle Hall on its “Nashville Nine"—a list of local buildings most in danger of demolition. It was saved when the Aerial Development group purchased it in 2013 for $700,000. After two years, and a $500,000 restoration, Workmen’s Circle Hall was honored at the Preservation Awards by the Nashville Historical Foundation.

Built in 1859, it first served as the home of Isaac Garretson, an elder statesman in the local Jewish community. The house was later sold to Alexander Iser and then Jacob Bloomstein, both members of Nashville’s Jewish business and religious elite. In 1875, Bloomstein enlarged the house for his growing family of ten children. His daughter, Elizabeth, born in 1857, was one of the first graduates of Peabody College for Teachers. She obtained a master’s degree at the University of Nashville and returned to Peabody, her alma mater, as a history professor and librarian. Elizabeth Bloomstein was also active in several Nashville civic organizations including the Ladies’ Hermitage Association, Twentieth Century Club, and the United Daughters of the Confederacy.

The Workmen’s Circle purchased the building for use as its Hall Branch 641. Founded in 1900 in New York City, the Workmen’s Circle is an American Jewish fraternal organization. The Workmen’s Circle used this townhouse as a residence, lodge, and community center. The organization also provided aid and support to Jewish workers and immigrants and provided community and hospital services. The building retains the original cast concrete sign. Look for it at the top of the building with the name written in English and Yiddish. The Nashville branch of Workmen’s Circle closed in the 1970s, and the building has housed several other businesses since.

Continue heading north on Fifth Avenue South, turn RIGHT onto Peabody Street. Walk two blocks and turn LEFT onto Fourth Avenue South. As you continue north, towards Broadway, the next stop is at the corner of Fourth Avenue and Korean Veterans Boulevard. This building formerly housed St. Paul’s African Methodist Episcopal Church.

Tour Stops
Full Record & Citation
Title Workmen's Circle Hall
Creator Nashville Historical Foundation
Author Marley Abbott, MTSU Student; 2019
Date 1859; 1927; 2013; 2015
Address 521 Fifth Avenue South, Nashville, TN 37203
Description The Arbiter Ring, also known as the Workmen’s Circle, is a Yiddish-speaking, Jewish fraternal organization founded by Eastern European immigrants in 1900. The Nashville chapter’s house, built in 1859 for Isaac Garritsen, was constructed in the Italianate style. The building front features a concrete sign with the organization’s name in both English and Yiddish on the second level. Later owners also included Alexander Iser and Jacob Bloomstein, both of whom were active members in Nashville’s Jewish community. In 1927, the building was purchased by the Workmen’s Circle Branch 641 and was used for meetings, community gatherings, and lodging until 1952. In 2009, Irene Bradley purchased it to use as a commercial kitchen. It was then purchased by Inspiration LLC in 2013 for $700,000 and sold to the Hard 8 Working Group two years later.
Type Building
Coverage Area 1
Source Isaac Garritsen, original owner
Contributor Jacob Bloomstein; Irene Bradley; Aerial Development; David Elsbach; Mark Elsbach; Alexander Iser; Workmen's Circle
Subject Antebellum; Architecture; Civic Organizations; Downtown; New South; Religion
Keywords Adaptive Reuse, Buildings, Italianate, Judaism, Fraternal Organizations, Workmen's Circle Hall
Rights CC BY-NC 4.0
Playback speed 1x
0:000:00